Fiberglass vs. Porcelain vs. Acrylic: What Can Be Reglazed in the Bay Area?

Before scheduling a bathtub refinishing project, you need to know what material your tub is made from. Different materials require different preparation techniques, different coatings, and—in some cases—have different expected outcomes. For Bay Area homeowners dealing with everything from Victorian clawfoot tubs to mid-century fiberglass units, understanding your tub material is the first step to a successful refinishing project.

The good news is that virtually all common bathtub materials can be professionally refinished. The techniques and costs vary, but a skilled refinisher can transform fiberglass, porcelain-on-steel, porcelain-on-cast-iron, and acrylic tubs into gleaming surfaces that look brand new.

Identifying Your Tub Material

Many homeowners do not know what their bathtub is made from. Here are simple tests to identify your tub material.

The Magnet Test

This is the quickest way to narrow down possibilities:

1. Find a refrigerator magnet
2. Try to stick it to the side of your tub (not an enameled surface)
3. Check if it holds

Results:

• Magnet sticks strongly: Cast iron or steel (porcelain enamel coating)
• Magnet does not stick: Fiberglass, acrylic, or possibly a composite

The Knock Test

Gently knock on the side of the tub with your knuckle:

• Dull, heavy thud: Cast iron
• Hollow, ringing sound: Steel (lighter porcelain) or fiberglass
• Plasticky, slightly hollow sound: Acrylic

Visual Clues

Cast iron tubs: Extremely heavy, thick walls, often freestanding or have decorative feet. Common in pre-1950 San Francisco homes.

Porcelain-on-steel tubs: Lighter than cast iron, often built-in, thin walls. Common in 1950s-1980s construction. May show rust spots if enamel is damaged.

Fiberglass tubs: Often have a visible seam where the tub and surround meet. May feel slightly flexible when pressed. Common in 1970s-1990s homes.

Acrylic tubs: Similar to fiberglass but thicker, more rigid, and often higher quality. Common in homes built after 1990 and in renovations.

Porcelain-on-Cast-Iron: The Classic Choice

Cast iron tubs with porcelain enamel coating are the premier bathtub material, found throughout San Francisco's Victorian and Edwardian homes, Berkeley's craftsman bungalows, and older neighborhoods across the Peninsula.

Characteristics

• Weight: 300-500 pounds empty
• Wall thickness: 1/4 to 1/2 inch of iron, plus enamel
• Heat retention: Excellent (keeps bathwater warm longer)
• Lifespan of original enamel: 30-75 years with care
• Lifespan after refinishing: 10-15+ years

Refinishing Process

Cast iron tubs refinish beautifully because the substrate is stable and the porcelain provides an excellent base for coatings. The process involves:

1. Deep cleaning: Remove soap scum, body oils, and mineral deposits
2. Chip and rust repair: Fill chips with waterproof filler, treat any rust with converter
3. Etching: Acid etch or sand to create bonding profile
4. Priming: Apply bonding primer specifically designed for porcelain
5. Coating: Spray 2-4 coats of acrylic urethane
6. Curing: Allow 24-72 hours before use

Bay Area Costs

• Standard built-in cast iron tub: $400-700
• Clawfoot or freestanding cast iron tub: $700-1,700 (includes exterior refinishing and feet restoration)

Best For

Cast iron refinishing is ideal for:

• Historic home preservation
• Homeowners who love the "heft" and heat retention of cast iron
• Situations where replacement would be difficult (cast iron tubs are extremely heavy to remove)
• Eichler homes where slab construction makes replacement costly

Porcelain-on-Steel: The Mid-Century Workhorse

Steel tubs with porcelain enamel became the standard for suburban construction from the 1950s through 1980s. They are found throughout the Peninsula, South Bay, and East Bay in homes built during the post-war housing boom.

Characteristics

• Weight: 70-100 pounds
• Wall thickness: Thin steel (16-20 gauge) with thin enamel layer
• Heat retention: Moderate (less than cast iron)
• Lifespan of original enamel: 15-30 years
• Lifespan after refinishing: 10-15 years

Refinishing Considerations

Steel tubs are good candidates for refinishing, but the thinner enamel and substrate create some specific challenges:

Rust vulnerability: Because the steel is thinner than cast iron, rust damage can penetrate more quickly once the enamel is breached. Prompt repair of chips is important.

Flexing: Steel tubs can flex slightly under weight and during water filling. This creates stress on the refinished coating. High-quality flexible coatings are essential.

Surface quality: Some steel tubs have enamel that was applied less thickly than cast iron, resulting in a surface that may show more of the underlying steel texture after refinishing.

Bay Area Costs

• Standard steel tub: $350-600
• Steel tub with tile surround refinishing: $800-1,500

Best For

Steel tub refinishing works well for:

• Budget-conscious updates
• Rental properties and landlord renovations
• Tubs in acceptable condition that simply need color updating
• Staging before home sale

Fiberglass: The 1970s-1990s Standard

Fiberglass tubs (technically fiberglass-reinforced plastic with gel coat surface) became popular in the 1970s as a lightweight, affordable alternative to metal tubs. They are found throughout Bay Area homes built in this era, especially in Mountain View, Fremont, and newer parts of Oakland.

Characteristics

• Weight: 60-90 pounds
• Construction: Fiberglass mat reinforced plastic with gel coat surface
• Heat retention: Poor (water cools quickly)
• Lifespan of original gel coat: 15-25 years
• Lifespan after refinishing: 7-12 years

Refinishing Considerations

Fiberglass presents unique challenges for refinishing:

Surface porosity: Gel coat develops micro-pores over time that absorb stains and cleaning chemicals. Deep cleaning and proper preparation are essential.

Flexibility: Fiberglass tubs flex significantly under weight, creating stress on refinished coatings. Specialized flexible coatings and careful application are required.

Previous repairs: Many fiberglass tubs have been patched or repaired over the years. These repairs may not bond well with refinishing coatings and may need removal.

Spider cracks: Fiberglass can develop stress cracks that spread outward from impact points. These must be stabilized before refinishing.

Bay Area Costs

• Fiberglass tub only: $400-650
• Fiberglass tub/shower combo: $600-900
• One-piece fiberglass surround: $800-1,200

Best For

Fiberglass refinishing is appropriate for:

• Units in acceptable structural condition (no flexing, no major cracks)
• Tubs where the primary issue is staining or surface wear
• Situations where replacement is impractical (ADUs or small bathrooms with limited access)
• Temporary fixes while saving for full renovation

When to Consider Replacement Instead

Fiberglass tubs should be replaced rather than refinished when:

• Significant flexing indicates structural weakness
• Spider cracks are extensive or spreading
• The tub has been refinished previously with poor results
• Water damage is visible beneath the surface

Acrylic: The Modern Standard

Acrylic tubs became the material of choice for quality construction and renovations starting in the 1990s. They are common in Bay Area homes built in the last 30 years and in recently renovated bathrooms.

Characteristics

• Weight: 80-100 pounds
• Construction: Thermoformed acrylic sheet over fiberglass backing
• Heat retention: Better than fiberglass, less than cast iron
• Lifespan of original surface: 20-30 years
• Lifespan after refinishing: 10-15 years

Refinishing Considerations

Acrylic refinishes well because the material is more stable and consistent than fiberglass:

Surface quality: Acrylic has a non-porous, consistent surface that accepts coatings uniformly.

Flexibility: Less flexible than fiberglass but still requires appropriate coating systems.

Color matching: Acrylic tubs come in many colors. Matching the original color for spot repairs can be challenging.

Previous condition: Scratches in acrylic can often be polished out rather than requiring full refinishing.

Bay Area Costs

• Acrylic tub only: $400-650
• Acrylic tub/shower combo: $600-950
• Acrylic jetted tub (interior only, no jets): $500-800

Best For

Acrylic refinishing is ideal for:

• Surface scratches, stains, or color updating
• Jetted tubs where the jets function well but the surface is worn
• Tubs where scratches are too deep for polishing but the structure is sound

Comparison Chart: Materials at a Glance

Factor	Cast Iron	Steel	Fiberglass	Acrylic
Weight	300-500 lbs	70-100 lbs	60-90 lbs	80-100 lbs
Heat Retention	Excellent	Moderate	Poor	Moderate
Durability	Excellent	Good	Fair	Good
Refinish Success Rate	High	High	Moderate	High
Refinish Longevity	10-15+ years	10-15 years	7-12 years	10-15 years
Bay Area Cost Range	$400-1,700	$350-600	$400-1,200	$400-950

What About Composites and Cultured Marble?

Cultured Marble

Cultured marble (also called cultured stone or cast polymers) is a composite material made of ground stone mixed with resin. Common in vanity tops and some tub surrounds.

Can it be refinished? Yes, with specific techniques. Cultured marble surfaces can become dull and stained over time. Professional refinishing can restore the appearance, though the surface requires careful preparation to ensure adhesion.

Bay Area cost: $300-600 for vanity tops; $700-1,200 for tub surrounds

Solid Surface (Corian, etc.)

Solid surface materials like Corian can often be renewed through sanding and buffing rather than coating. Light scratches can be sanded out, and the entire surface can be polished to restore shine.

For deeper damage, refinishing with specialized coatings is possible but less common.

Material-Specific Maintenance Tips

Regardless of material, refinished tubs need gentle care. However, some material-specific tips apply.

Cast Iron and Steel

• Wipe dry after use to prevent hard water buildup
• Address any chips immediately to prevent rust (especially steel)
• Clean with non-abrasive products only

Fiberglass

• Avoid standing water in the tub between uses
• Use bathroom ventilation to reduce humidity
• Be gentle—the underlying material is more flexible than metal

Acrylic

• Avoid extreme temperature changes (do not pour boiling water directly)
• Use bath mats outside the tub (not suction-cup mats inside)
• Polish with automotive wax annually for extra protection

Related Reading

• Covering That 1970s Pink Tile: Your Options
• Victorian Clawfoot Tub Restoration in San Francisco
• Eichler Home Bathroom Updates: Preserving Mid-Century Character
• Chip Repair vs. Full Refinish: When a Touch-Up Is Enough
• Bay Area Water Hardness & Refinished Tub Maintenance

Not sure what your tub is made of? Get a free Bay Area assessment and we will identify your material and provide a custom quote.

---

RefinishQuote is the Bay Area's trusted source for transparent refinishing estimates.